How Long After a Car Accident Can You File an Injury Claim?

Getting into a car accident in Ohio is not that different from a car accident anywhere else. In fact, most people respond to being in an accident in Ohio in much the same way as they would in California, Texas, or Connecticut. It’s what you do after the accident that may make a big difference and a bigger impact on your life than you expected. 

Suing After a Car Accident

Not everyone sues after a car accident. However, in instances where you have been severely injured, or new injuries appear several months later you may want to sue. In the state of Ohio, can you sue if you change your mind after the fact? Are you able to file a claim despite the fact that you didn’t do within a month or two after the accident? Would a judge even allow the case to be heard at that point?

Undoubtedly, many of these questions spring to your mind. You may have other questions that only pertain to your accident too. Plymale Partnership in Columbus, OH can answer a lot of these questions.

Statute of Limitations

This thing called “statute of limitations” is a legal phrase that means to restrict would-be claimants from filing years after the incident occurred. Depending on the supposed crime, you only have “x” number of months or years to file a lawsuit. In Ohio, the statute of limitations on car accidents is two years. That is actually a pretty generous amount of time to file a claim against the other driver. When you take into consideration that many internal injuries are not immediately discoverable or discovered, it’s a good amount of time to file.

If you did not go to a hospital to be examined after your accident, you will need some sort of medical record that shows injury and attests to injury being tied to a car accident. A car accident attorney can’t defend you if there’s not enough substantial evidence to show that you were (unwittingly) injured and did not seek medical help. If you were injured but simply refused care until you felt or noticed something was really wrong, gather the medical documentation before you file. 

Hearing Your Case in Court

Unlike all the dramatic legal TV shows you could rattle off, many cases are actually settled outside of court. Car accident lawyers frequently settle cases without going before a judge. If you are concerned that a judge would not be willing to hear an almost two-year-old lawsuit about injuries in a car accident, don’t be. Most judges don’t hear these cases because they rarely get that far. Lawyers settle the cases, have everyone sign the paperwork, and collect the settlement checks. 

It’s only when the case might present a questionable doubt or the other driver involved refuses to settle that a case might go to court. If your case does go to court, judges know what’s on their docket months in advance and they know about the two-year statute. You would be fine either way.

Evidence You Will Need

Besides presenting with injuries that can be tied back to the car accident, you will need documentation of missed work hours, how the injuries prevent you from working your current or previous job, any potential therapies or rehab you have to go through, and if applicable, the documentation for mental and psychological harm. If any of these don’t apply to you, then just gather what you can. 

What You Can Reasonably Expect

Ohio law allows you to recoup lost wages, payment for medical bills and related medical expenses, and pain and suffering. If you do not file soon after the accident, pain and suffering may not be entertained during mediation or the court hearing. If the case never goes to court, it may be resolved within a few months after filing. If it goes to court, it might take a couple of years depending on how long the wait is to get your case on the docket.

Nobody really becomes insanely wealthy from a car accident case unless the situation was particularly extreme and there was a loss of life, loss of limbs, or loss of eyesight. Yet Plymale Partnership has managed to get its clients over $70 million in the years that the firm has been open. What you get will be fair and reasonable for the extent of your injuries and losses. 

Contact Plymale Partnership in Columbus, OH 

Contact Plymale Partnership in Columbus, OH regarding your car accident case. Make sure it has been less than two years since your crash before scheduling a consultation. Any cases that are older than two years have surpassed the statute of limitations and cannot be tried or mediated for compensation. Plymale Partnership are awaiting your call.

Ohio Car Accident Laws

Car accidents occur all too often in Ohio, and it’s important to know the laws surrounding them. This article will provide an overview of accident laws in Ohio, including the statute of limitations, driver’s duties after an accident, insurance requirements, and damages recoverable in a lawsuit.

In Ohio, the statute of limitations for filing a personal injury lawsuit is two years from the date of the accident. If you don’t file a lawsuit within two years of the accident, you won’t be able to pursue any legal action against the other driver.  

Driver’s Duties After an Accident

Ohio law requires drivers to stay at the scene of the accident and exchange information with the other driver, including name, address, driver’s license number, and insurance information.

Ohio requires drivers to carry minimum auto insurance coverage, including $25,000 per person for bodily injury, $50,000 per accident for bodily injury, and $25,000 for property damage. 

Drivers must also carry uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage, which covers the insured driver if someone hits them without insurance or with insufficient coverage. 

What a Car Accident Lawyer Does After an Accident

Car accident lawyers are responsible for helping injured individuals and their families to obtain the compensation they are entitled to for their medical bills and other costs associated with the crash. 

A car accident lawyer will handle various tasks, including gathering evidence and information about the crash, speaking to witnesses, filing insurance claims, and handling legal proceedings. They can also help you understand the laws that apply to your case and ensure you get the compensation you deserve.  

Car Accident Claims Statute of Limitations in Ohio

Injury claims resulting from auto accidents must be made within two years of the collision. The statute of limitations refers to this. The victim may not be able to get any compensation for their damages if a claim is not made within this period.

There are caps on the number of damages awarded in car accident cases. This means that even if you are entitled to a large compensation, you may only receive a certain amount.  

The caps on damages vary depending on the type of claim. For instance, in Ohio, the cap on non-economic damages (e.g. pain and suffering) is $250,000 in most cases. However, in cases involving “catastrophic injury”, the cap is $500,000.  

Understanding Ohio car accident laws is essential if you’ve been in a crash. These laws, known as Ohio car accident laws, set out the legal framework for who is responsible for paying for the medical bills, lost wages, and other costs associated with a car accident. 

Fault in a Car Accident in Ohio?  

The fault system for auto insurance is in effect in Ohio. This implies that whoever caused the accident is accountable for its consequences. If the other driver caused the collision, the at-fault party or their insurance provider might be liable for covering the other driver’s medical expenses, missed earnings, and other accident-related expenses.

It’s important to take certain steps to protect your rights. First, you should contact the police and file a police report. This will provide you with an official record of the accident. Next, you should gather evidence from the scene of the accident, such as pictures and witness statements. 

Car accidents can be complicated, and it’s important to understand the laws governing them in Ohio. These laws, known as Ohio car accident laws, set out the legal framework for who is responsible for paying for the medical bills, lost wages, and other costs associated with a car accident. 

The amount of damages each party will be liable for will then be determined according to the percentage of fault assigned. For example, if one party is assigned 50 percent of the fault, they may be liable for 50 percent of the damages.

Common Injuries in Car Accidents  

Car accidents can result in various injuries from small scratches and bruises to more serious injuries, including shattered bones, head injuries, and spinal cord damage.

If hurt in a car accident, you might be eligible for financial assistance for your medical expenses, lost earnings, suffering, and other crash-related expenses.

In Ohio, the responsible party or insurance company may be responsible for these costs. It’s important to understand the compensation you may be entitled to for your car accident injuries in Ohio. 

It’s also important to contact an experienced car accident lawyer as soon as possible, as they can help you understand your rights and ensure you get the compensation you deserve.

Paying Medical Bills After a Car Accident

The at-fault person or their insurance provider may be liable for covering the other driver’s medical expenses, missed earnings, and other accident-related expenses.

In Ohio, all motorists are required to maintain a minimum level of liability coverage. If the other driver is at fault, this coverage will cover related charges like missed wages, medical expenses, and other incidental expenses. If you were at fault for the collision, it also covers damage to the other driver’s vehicle.

What Is the Average Settlement for a Semi-truck Accident?

Semi-truck accidents are traumatic and dangerous events that can result in serious injuries. If you or a loved one has been injured or lost property in a semi-truck accident, you may be entitled to a semi-truck accident settlement. These settlements, however, are not fixed amounts and may vary greatly depending on several variables.

What Is the Average Semi-truck Accident Settlement?

In most cases, large settlements are hard to come by when it comes to semi-trucks and liability lawsuits. However, there are exceptions to this rule. An experienced attorney can help you determine what type of semi-truck accident or injury you have suffered and how much money you may receive in compensation. This amount may range anywhere from $20,000 up to seven figures, depending on the circumstances of your case.

What Are the Factors That Affect Semi-truck Accident Settlement?

  1. Liability: Who was at fault in the accident? Who was driving the truck?
  1. Injuries: Are you currently suffering from physical injuries that are debilitating or painful? If yes, how long do you expect them to last? Do you have any mental or psychological problems resulting from this accident? Traumatic brain injury, TBI, spinal cord injury, and concussion usually add additional medical bills that result in a higher settlement amount.
  1. Insurance: What insurance coverage do the trucking company and its drivers have? Does the collision policy include semi-trucks? Does it cover medical bills, lost income, pain and suffering, and permanent injuries? What is the company’s deductible?
  1. Court Proceedings: How much can you expect to receive if you take this case to court? The truck attorney may guide their client through the settlement process and bring their case to court if they believe this is the best option.

These factors may result in higher compensation depending on how well a truck accident lawyer can present his case.

Semi-truck accident settlements may be far less than the fair compensation amount. For those injured and seeking compensation, it is important to hire an experienced truck accident attorney who can guide them throughout the process in making sure that they get the maximum compensation possible.

The Truth About the Geico HPV Case

The Truth About the Geico HPV Case

This past weekend, a friend of mine told me a fantastical story about Geico Insurance Company being ordered to pay more than $5 million to a lady who had contracted the HPV virus in a car insured by Geico.  I told him that the story must be apocryphal.  Interested in whether the story had any merit, I conducted a quick Google search and found at least 100 articles from different “news” organizations claiming that Geico had been ordered to pay the lady $5.2 million by a court in Missouri.  I then also heard the same claim being made by Trevor Noah on his talk show.  Being extremely skeptical about these claims based on my experience in personal injury actions, I decided to conduct some research.  The following is what I discovered.  .

The Allegations

In 2017, two adults, identified as M.O. and M.B. in the legal actions, engaged in consensual sexual intercourse in M.B.’s vehicle, which was insured by Geico.  M.G. also possessed an umbrella liability policy with Geico.  Unknown to M.O., M.B. had been previously diagnosed with Human Papillomavirus (HPV), a fact he did not disclose to M.O., who was later diagnosed with HPV.  M.O. sought compensation from M.B. for causing her to contract this contagious, and sometimes deadly, disease.

Since M.B.’s policies with Geico provided coverage to M.B. for injuries that arose out of the “use” of M.B’s vehicle, M.O. attempted to settle her claim against M.B. within the monetary limits of the policy of $1 million.  Geico refused to engage in settlement discussions with M.O.  As such, she informed Geico that she intended to file a legal action against M.B. for her injuries.  Geico then refused to either indemnify M.B. or to even provide a defense for him.

The Law

While I am unfamiliar with the specific law in Missouri, most states require people who have been diagnosed with an STD to disclose that fact to any sexual partner. In fact, in Ohio, failing to disclose an STD diagnosis to a sexual partner is a crime, either as a misdemeanor or a felony offense if the STD is HIV.  Further, a person who fails to disclose his/her STD diagnosis can also be held liable for monetary damages in a civil action, which is what we have in this case.

The Legal Actions

Apparently in Missouri, parties to a civil case can submit the entire matter to arbitration and agree to be bound by that decision, which the parties did in this case.  Just as in a trial before a jury or judge, the parties are given an equal opportunity to submit evidence in the form of testimony from witnesses and physical exhibits, and to make arguments in support of their case.   Although Geico was made aware of this process, it chose not to get involved and not to hire an attorney to represent M.B.  In my experience, insurance companies almost always hire an attorney to represent their insured if there is even the slightest possibility that it may need to extend coverage to its insured.  Geico simply decided to take that risk in this case.  

The case eventually proceeded to an arbitration hearing, during which both parties were afforded the opportunity to submit evidence.  At the conclusion of the hearing, the arbitrator awarded M.O. $5.2 million for her damages.  A Missouri court later adopted that award and issued a judgment against M.B, not against Geico.  While Geico attempted to intervene in the action following the arbitration decision, the Missouri court found that Geico was given the opportunity to participate and defend M.B. at the arbitration and simply chose not do so, and as such, dismissed it from the case.  A Missouri Appellate Court affirmed that decision.

The Truth

At around the same time as the arbitration hearing, Geico filed an action in federal court seeking a declaration that it was not obligated to extend coverage to M.B.  As of the date of this article, that action is still pending; however, many news organizations have falsely reported that Geico has been ordered to pay M.O. $5.2 million.  That is simply not true.   The issue of coverage is yet to be decided, but that has not stopped Geico’s public relations department from misinforming and misleading the public into believing that it has been ordered to pay the award.  Based on my reading of the pleadings filed in the case, I believe that M.O. will likely have a difficult time convincing the court that coverage should be extended to M.B., in which case, she would receive none of the $5.2 million award.  Further, barring some extraordinary circumstances, Geico’s overall exposure is likely limited to the $1 million policy limit.  So, even if the federal court determines that Geico must indemnify M.B., $4.2 million of the award will likely go unpaid.  

I am disappointed in the failure of many journalists to accurately report the facts of this case, and to once again spread false information about the legal system, especially relating to tort cases.   But then again, accurately reporting the facts is not good business for many “news” organizations, especially those in the conservative media that care little about the facts.  The attorneys at Plymale Partnership care about the truth and about protecting the rights of injury victims.  While insurance companies have the resources to spend millions of dollars on misinformation campaigns, individual injury victims lack those same resources.   I hope that this article serves, in even a small way, to combat that effort.  

The Fallacy of Frivolous Lawsuits

The Perception

If you stop 10 people on the street and ask them about lawsuits, 8 or 9 of them will likely tell you that there are too many of them.  They will also likely tell you that frivolous lawsuits make up a generous percentage of those lawsuits, especially in injury cases, and that juries are “out of control” by either finding defendants responsible when they are not or by rendering large and unreasonable monetary verdicts. Many will claim that the legal system is broken and that government intervention is necessary to stem the tide of these frivolous actions.  However, neither the facts nor my personal experience supports this perception.

The Reality

According to a study conducted by the American Bar Association, fewer than 4% of civil cases filed in 2015 in U.S. state courts were “tort cases” and only 2 out of 1,000 people filed tort actions in 2015. [1]  A “tort” is simply a private or civil wrong that causes damage or injury to another person.   Contract cases accounted for the majority of these filings, and the majority of those were either debt collection or landlord/tenant matters.  In another study, of the tort cases filed in 2013, three-quarters of them resulted in recoveries of less than $12,200.00, and only .2% resulted in recoveries exceeding $500,000.00. [2]  That means that only 1 out of 250,000 people in 2013 received a recovery of more than $500,000.   Based on my experience as a trial lawyer, the people who comprise this .0004% likely suffered catastrophic injuries, including paralysis, loss of a limb or death.  On the other hand, 375 of them would have received a recovery of less than $12,200.

Notwithstanding the actual facts, large businesses, especially multi-billion-dollar insurance companies, have convinced the general public that too many frivolous lawsuits are being filed and that juries are rendering unfair and unreasonable verdicts.  I will agree with the insurance companies on one claim, that juries can render unfair and unreasonable verdicts, but for too little, not too much.  I have yet to review one case in Ohio where a jury rendered a verdict exceeding $500,000 against a defendant who was not liable and that did not involve a Plaintiff who had suffered serious and life-changing injuries.   On the other hand, I have seen numerous jury verdicts for less than even the Plaintiff’s medical bills.  However, I do not blame individual jurors for rendering such inadequate verdicts because the business community, especially insurance companies, have done such a great job of misleading and deceiving them.   Spending millions of dollars on a disinformation campaign will often have that effect (please see my next article about Geico’s efforts to misinform the public about a case involving a Plaintiff contracting the HPV virus).   

The Jury System

I have great faith in our jury system.  It is what largely sets us apart from other countries.  It is one of the few opportunities the citizens of this country have to ensure that the rights of all people are preserved.  The right to a jury trial in a civil action is guaranteed by both the U.S. Constitution in the 7th Amendment and in the Ohio Constitution in Article I, section 5.  Unfortunately, the Ohio legislature, along with the legislatures of several other states, with the support of the insurance industry, has seen fit to infringe upon that right by enacting “tort reform” measures, citing to non-existent frivolous tort actions and excessive jury verdicts, which we know do not exist.  In Ohio, any jury verdict exceeding $250,000, or $350,000 if the Plaintiff’s economic damages exceed $116,667.00, will be automatically reduced by the court unless the Plaintiff’s injuries are of a type contained on a small and limited list (and that amount has not been increased since the law was initially passed in 2005).   

In my experience, jurors are in the best position to decide what is fair and just – not elected officials sitting in the Ohio Statehouse who know absolutely nothing about the case being tried.  During a trial, juries will hear testimony from multiple witnesses, including expert witnesses like surgeons, engineers and scientists, and they will be able to review and scrutinize tangible evidence, which often includes medical records, photographs, diagrams, written statements, etc.  So, the clear message from our state government is that regular people are either too stupid to know what is fair and just or are not to be trusted, even though those same people considered the actual evidence in the case.  Rather, as our elected officials, they are just plain smarter and able to predict what is fair and just, without needing to consider the actual evidence.  The next time you vote, please pay special attention to the voting record of your state representative, state senator or governor.  I believe many of you will be surprised at how many of them vote to infringe the rights of the people in favor of the interests of big business.  

I will leave you with this last thought.  I have filed hundreds of tort cases in my 24-year career, and in almost every, single case, the defendant’s attorney has requested a jury trial.  A jury trial is not automatic.  At least one of the parties must formally request a jury trial or the case will be heard by the assigned judge.  To be clear, in almost every tort case, the defendant’s attorney is hired and paid by the defendant’s insurance company.  So, this begs the question: if juries are not to be trusted as the insurance companies have so claimed over the last several decades, why would the attorneys they hire request one?  The simple answer is that they have been given their cake and been allowed to eat it too.  They have convinced the Ohio legislature to limit a jury’s power, and Constitutional right, to render a verdict based on the actual evidence, and at the same time convinced the jury, before any evidence has actually been admitted, that frivolous lawsuits and excessive jury verdicts are rampant.  It’s a win-win for the billion-dollar insurance industry and a lose-lose for injury victims.  I, along with the other attorneys at Plymale Partnership, have worked diligently over the years to fight and counter the misinformation campaigns of the insurance industry and its supporters.  I hope that this article continues to serve that effort, however small that impact may be.

[1] Cassens Weiss, Debra. “Tort Suits in State Courts Are ‘Down Sharply’ as Contract Claims Grow.” ABA Journal 26 July 2017.

[2] Civil Justice Initiative: The Landscape of Civil Litigation in State Courts

Uber & Lyft Accident FAQ

Ordering an Uber or Lyft has become one of the most popular ways to travel from one place to another, so it should not be shocking that accidents among rideshare drivers have become an issue. In fact, a study conducted by professors at the University of Chicago and Rice University determined that the launch of ride-sharing platforms, such as Uber or Lyft, in a new city is associated with a 2-3% increase in the number of fatal accidents and motor vehicle fatalities. Additionally, some research shows that rideshare drivers are also contributing to increased congestion on the roads, which in turn contributes to a higher rate of collisions because of the increased number of cars on the road. So, before you schedule your next ride, here is some information to keep you informed in the event that the rideshare vehicle you are traveling in is involved in an accident.

What should I do if the Uber or Lyft vehicle I am riding in is involved in an accident?

First, as with any motor vehicle collision, make sure that all involved parties are safe and notify law enforcement and medical personnel, but you should also contact the rideshare company and report the incident.

Second, if it is safe to do so, take photos of the scene. Photos should include all the vehicles involved in the collision including the Uber or Lyft vehicle. Also, be sure to check for traffic or security cameras surrounding the area of the collision. Video documentation provides additional evidence that will support your claim.

Third, you should collect contact information for the driver of your vehicle, other passengers if it is a pool-share ride, and the driver of the other involved vehicle(s).

As always, you can refer to our evidence collection blogs to determine what other information should be collected at the scene.

How do Uber and Lyft Insurance Policies Work?

Both Uber and Lyft carry an insurance policy for personal injury, property damage, and death that is caused by their drivers during an active ride. An “active ride” usually begins from the time the ride is requested until it is cleared when the passenger is dropped off at their location. This policy can cover damages including your injuries, the past and future costs of medical treatment for injuries, lost income due to injury, and past and future physical or mental pain and suffering.

  • It should also be noted that the coverage for both Uber and Lyft is based upon the driver’s activities at the time of the accident, which means that coverage may not be available on a particular accident and may revert to the driver’s personal insurance policy. Below are examples of Uber and Lyft policies regarding coverage:
  • Uber and Lyft are not liable for any accidents that occur when drivers are not working.
  • If an Uber or Lyft driver has their app on and can work, both the Uber or Lyft policy and the driver’s insurance policy will go into effect should a collision occur.
  • If a passenger is in an Uber or Lyft driver’s vehicle and a collision does occur it will be covered by the rideshare company’s insurance policy.

As you can see, being involved in a collision while in a rideshare vehicle is a very complicated issue and requires the guidance of an experienced personal injury attorney to speak with the insurance company, and, if necessary, the court on your behalf. If you were the passenger in an Uber or Lyft motor vehicle collision, the attorneys at Plymale Partnership at 614-542-0220 so we can help you get the compensation that you deserve.

Vlog–What To Do If You Are Injured In A Slip & Fall Accident

https://youtu.be/xkXg87kfMk0

A Guide To Preparing For A Deposition

If you are a participant in a personal injury law suit many times you will be asked to give a deposition to document your testimony in the matter. Although it may sound intimidating, a deposition is your opportunity to tell your side of the story and demonstrate to the defendant and the insurance company that your claim deserves just compensation. Below we will discuss the basics of a deposition and how to best represent yourself during the process.

What Is A Deposition

A deposition is a formal legal process in which your testimony in a matter will be taken through the asking and answering of questions. During the deposition you are under oath and all the information you provide will be recorded in a written format that can be used in a later court proceeding. Normally, the deposition takes place in a conference room in either your attorney or the defense attorney’s office, however, due to Covid-19 many depositions are taking place over video conference software to keep all parties safe.

Who Is There and How Long Will It Take?

Once you are at the deposition you will notice at least two additional people in the room besides yourself and your attorney. These people are typically the defendant’s attorney who is there on behalf of the insurance company as well as the court reporter who transcribes everything that is said on the record during the deposition. There is no set amount of time for a deposition to take place, but the average deposition will take a couple of hours.

What Types of Questions Will Be Asked?

Depositions cover a wide range of information and your attorney will prepare you for these questions prior to the actual event; however, below are the most common areas covered:

  • Background Information (Name, Address, Education)
  • Facts of the Accident (How & Where it Occurred, Who Was Involved)
  • Your Injuries That Are A Result of The Accident
  • Your Medical Treatment
  • Prior Medical History
  • How Your Life Has Been Impacted by The Accident
  • Lost Wages or Employment
  • Your Current Condition

How Do I Answer the Questions Being Asked?

First, while it may seem obvious, the most important thing you should remember is to tell the truth. You are under oath during a deposition and intentionally not telling the truth is the crime of perjury. Just as important, answering questions truthfully is the only way that you can guarantee that you will not be misrepresented in the future. Secondly, before answering any question that is presented to you, make sure you take a moment to make sure you understand the question that is being asked. If you do not understand the question or are confused, you need to make that clear to the opposing attorney. Simply tell the attorney that you do not understand the question and ask them to repeat or rephrase the question until you do understand. Third, when answering questions, you should give short and direct answers to the questions. Remember, a deposition is considered direct testimony and anything that you say can be used against you in the future. Thus, the best answer is the answer that fully and succinctly answers the questions that was asked. Finally, remember to remain calm. Do not allow yourself to become upset or frustrated with the defendant’s attorney. While the purpose of a deposition is to obtain information it is also a chance for all of the parties to see how well you would testify as a witness in trial. Your attorney is present at the deposition to protect your interests and if they feel there is something inappropriate happening, they will step in and take care of the situation.

If you have additional questions regarding depositions or are in need of a personal injury attorney, please contact our office at 614.542.0220.

Protecting Yourself In A Slip & Fall

If you have been injured in a store, on someone else’s property, or even your own property, it can be a frightening experience.  However, it is important that you stop, gather yourself, and make sure that you collect the proper evidence to help support your claim and, if necessary, a lawsuit.

When you have been injured by an object in a store, or from a slip or fall, there is no dedicated line to call for someone to come out and investigate the situation.  Therefore, the evidence collection often falls on you, or a friend or family member you call upon to help you.  In these types of incidents, early evidence collection can be the difference between a successful or unsuccessful injury claim or lawsuit.  To avoid that situation, our office recommends that you take the following steps to protect yourself:

  • If it is safe to do so, take photographs or video of the area around where the incident took place, specifically what caused the incident (i.e., what you fell on, what cut or injured you, etc.).  In these types of incidents, the surrounding area is incredibly important and should be completely documented to the best of your ability. 
  • If you have been injured in a business, once you have documented what caused the incident, move to a safe location, and ask to speak with manager or safety personnel to complete an incident report. If you have been injured on someone else’s property, then, after documenting what caused the incident, step away from the situation, and take the time to write down what has happened.  When creating an incident report be sure to include the following information:
    • Date, time, and location of the incident
    • Names of everyone involved, including witnesses
    • Events that led up to the incident
    • Environmental conditions (sun, rain, snow, etc.)
    • Circumstances of the slip or fall
    • Specific injuries
    • Damage to equipment or area
    • Request that all video footage be collected and saved in anticipation for a possible claim
  • While at the scene, take pictures of any visible bruising or other injuries as well as any marks or rips to your clothing. If you have fallen, you should also make sure to photograph the entire outfit you were wearing that day.
  • Take the time to look around the general area of the incident and determine if any businesses or homes in the area may have cameras that could have captured the slip or fall. Business or residential cameras usually only retain recordings for 24-72 hours, so if you have been injured in a business, it is important to speak with manager or safety personnel to gather those tapes before the footage is destroyed. If you are having issues gathering the video documentation, it may be in your best interest to involve an attorney quickly because video documentation can be the deciding factor if there is a dispute as to the cause of the fall.

  • If there are witnesses to the incident, attempt to get their contact information, including their name and phone number, as well as a brief account of what they saw. Independent witnesses can provide additional credibility to your claim and can be used to help your case if necessary.

If you are transported from the scene via ambulance, you will have to rely on the business or property owner accurately documenting all the information and then potentially creating an incident report that may reflect their best interests rather than yours. However, to protect yourself, you may want to return to the scene after you are released or send a friend or family member to safely document the above information if possible.

Although collecting the information discussed may seem exhausting, having as much information about the incident as possible will allow insurance companies or attorneys to evaluate your claim and/or lawsuit more accurately. Once you have collected the evidence, your next step should be contacting a personal injury attorney that will use that information to protect your interests and provide you with the compensation that you deserve. If you have been injured in a slip or fall and would like to work with the attorneys at Plymale Partnership, please fill out the contact form on this page or call us at 614-542-0220.

If you have been injured in a store, on someone else’s property, or even your own property, it can be a frightening experience.  However, it is important that you stop, gather yourself, and make sure that you collect the proper evidence to help support your claim and, if necessary, a lawsuit.

When you have been injured by an object in a store, or from a slip or fall, there is no dedicated line to call for someone to come out and investigate the situation.  Therefore, the evidence collection often falls on you, or a friend or family member you call upon to help you.  In these types of incidents, early evidence collection can be the difference between a successful or unsuccessful injury claim or lawsuit.  To avoid that situation, our office recommends that you take the following steps to protect yourself:

  • If it is safe to do so, take photographs or video of the area around where the incident took place, specifically what caused the incident (i.e., what you fell on, what cut or injured you, etc.).  In these types of incidents, the surrounding area is incredibly important and should be completely documented to the best of your ability. 
  • If you have been injured in a business, once you have documented what caused the incident, move to a safe location, and ask to speak with manager or safety personnel to complete an incident report. If you have been injured on someone else’s property, then, after documenting what caused the incident, step away from the situation, and take the time to write down what has happened.  When creating an incident report be sure to include the following information:
    • Date, time, and location of the incident
    • Names of everyone involved, including witnesses
    • Events that led up to the incident
    • Environmental conditions (sun, rain, snow, etc.)
    • Circumstances of the slip or fall
    • Specific injuries
    • Damage to equipment or area
    • Request that all video footage be collected and saved in anticipation for a possible claim
  • While at the scene, take pictures of any visible bruising or other injuries as well as any marks or rips to your clothing. If you have fallen, you should also make sure to photograph the entire outfit you were wearing that day.
  • Take the time to look around the general area of the incident and determine if any businesses or homes in the area may have cameras that could have captured the slip or fall. Business or residential cameras usually only retain recordings for 24-72 hours, so if you have been injured in a business, it is important to speak with manager or safety personnel to gather those tapes before the footage is destroyed. If you are having issues gathering the video documentation, it may be in your best interest to involve an attorney quickly because video documentation can be the deciding factor if there is a dispute as to the cause of the fall.

  • If there are witnesses to the incident, attempt to get their contact information, including their name and phone number, as well as a brief account of what they saw. Independent witnesses can provide additional credibility to your claim and can be used to help your case if necessary.

If you are transported from the scene via ambulance, you will have to rely on the business or property owner accurately documenting all the information and then potentially creating an incident report that may reflect their best interests rather than yours. However, to protect yourself, you may want to return to the scene after you are released or send a friend or family member to safely document the above information if possible.

Although collecting the information discussed may seem exhausting, having as much information about the incident as possible will allow insurance companies or attorneys to evaluate your claim and/or lawsuit more accurately. Once you have collected the evidence, your next step should be contacting a personal injury attorney that will use that information to protect your interests and provide you with the compensation that you deserve. If you have been injured in a slip or fall and would like to work with the attorneys at Plymale Partnership, please fill out the contact form on this page or call us at 614-542-0220.

Car Accident Fault Determination

Determining fault (liability, negligence) in a motor vehicle accident may seem like a cut and dry situation because the person that caused the accident is normally assumed to be the negligent party. However, many times it can be extremely difficult to determine the at fault party. To complicate matters further, there are multiple entities such as law enforcement, insurance companies and the court system that all must make their own determination as to whom is responsible for the accident. Below we will examine how each entity determines fault in a motor vehicle collision.

Normally, the first interaction you have besides gathering information from the other party involved in the collision is with law enforcement. The police officer at the scene will interview both the drivers and witnesses and survey the scene until they believe that they have gathered enough information to determine fault. Once the officer has completed this process, they will then decide who is the responsible party and submit a police report. However, just because the police officer has concluded which party is at fault, it does not necessarily mean that the other driver will be held legally responsible for damages caused by the collision.

At some point after the collision, you will be in contact with your own insurance company or possibly the other driver’s insurance company. It is important to remember that no insurance company, even your own, is ever truly looking out for your best interest. So, always be aware that anything you tell an insurance company that is not helpful to your claim, can and will be used against you. After speaking to all the parties involved in the collision, the insurance companies will determine who was at fault for the accident. When it comes to fault determination usually it is decided that one party or the other will be determined to be at fault, however, this is not always the case. Sometimes insurance companies will assign fault among some or all the drivers involved in the collision including you. Thus, if the other party caused the collision, you must clearly and consistently relay that information to the insurance company and never waver from that fact.

At any point during the determination of fault process it may be necessary to hire an attorney. As a rule, the earlier you involve an attorney, the better protected your rights will be throughout the process as they will be able to guild you through the traps and pitfalls that arise. For example, if you hire an attorney after fault has been determined by the insurance company, the attorney may contact the insurance company and discuss how they arrived at their liability decision as well as adding any statements or other evidence they have obtained in support of your position. Your attorney is there to represent your interests and present evidence that supports your position when it comes to all aspects of your claim including fault determination.

It is important to remember that police reports and insurance companies’ decisions as to fault ARE NOT legally binding determinations of negligence or fault. Only the court can make the final and legal determination of fault in a collision. Ultimately, if an agreement cannot be reached as to whom is at fault for a collision it will be up to a judge or jury to make that determination.

If you have been injured in a motor vehicle accident and are going through this process, it may be time to speak with a qualified attorney. An experienced personal injury attorney will not only be able to protect your rights but will also be there to help and guide you through the claims process as well as any litigation or a trial concerning the collision.